60D Comment Response Spousal Consolidation

3/11/2024
Comments on Combined Application to Separate a Joint Consolidation Loan and Direct Consolidation
Loan Promissory Note

The purpose of this document is to summarize comments and concerns regarding the Department of
Education’s (ED) and Federal Student Aid’s (FSA) “Combined Application to Separate a Joint Application
Loan and Direct Consolidation Loan Promissory Note draft. These documented comments which were
contributed by SpousalConsolidation.DoUsPart! members in a March 6, 2024 meeting, are uploaded for
the Federal Registry comments on this application. Comments are organized by section.
Preamble Comments
No comments were made.
Section 1 & Section 2: Borrower and Co-Borrower Information
These sections are combined as they are intertwined.
•

The terms “borrower” and “co-borrower” need to be defined because they could be perceived
differently based on who is reading the application. JSCL’s have a borrower and co-borrower. In
many cases, the loan holder only has the borrower name for the loan and the Federal Student Aid
site only lists the loans under the original borrower name with no reference to the co-borrower.
For example, if a co-borrower inquires about the JSCL, they do not see any loans under their name,
and servicers do not provide information to the co-borrower because their name is not associated
with the loan.
FSA Response: The Department agrees that there may be some confusion for the borrowers
applying for the separation and reconsolidation. The language will be modified to clarify the
instructions for the borrowers.

•

On this application, it’s unclear whose name should go in Section 1 and whose name should go
in Section 2. Should the original borrower always go in the borrower section, or should the
name of the person completing this application, whether borrower or co-borrower, go in
Section 1 of this application?
FSA Response: The Department agrees that there may be some confusion for the borrowers
applying for the separation and reconsolidation. The language will be modified to clarify the
instructions for the borrowers.

•

Real-life example. A member of the group is divorced. Her ex-husband is the original borrower
of this loan, and she is the co-borrower. Does her ex-husband’s name go in Section 1? She is
unable to gather the required information from him for that section. If she puts her name in
Section 1, will she be denied because she is a co-borrower on the original loan?
FSA Response: This comment does not relate to the information collection.

•

Is it common to ask for an employer’s name on these applications? They don’t ask for this

SpousalConsolidation.DoUsPart! (DoUsPart!)
spousalconsolidation.douspart@gmail.com
www.douspart.org

1

3/11/2024
information under the Co-Borrower. While we assume each person holding the loan will
complete the application and be the “borrower” on their individual application, we do not want
to make assumptions because this historically leads to denial. We should not have to guess.
FSA Response: Other Direct Loan promissory notes also request employer information. The
employer may be contacted to help locate the borrower if the Department is unable to reach the
borrower using other contact information that the borrower has provided. The employer is not
contacted as part of the consolidation loan approval process.
The application does not ask for the co-borrower’s employer information because if both coborrowers wish to separate the joint debt into individual consolidation loans, each individual must
submit a separate application and provide their own employer information.
No change.
•

Should there be a different application for divorced applicants who will not have access to the
“co-borrower” information? If co-borrower information is missing, will the application be
denied? While Section 4 does provide an option for victims to file alone, the application seeks
co-borrower information. Clarity is needed.
FSA Response: The Department requests the co-borrower information to help identify the joint
consolidation loan being separated and to determine if the debt is being separated through the
joint or separate application process. The co-borrower information is required.
No change.

Section 3: Reference Information
•

No comment

Section 4: Joint or Separate Application to Separate a Joint Spousal Loan
•

Number 18. This relates to the Section 1 & 2 comment. Borrower and co-borrower terms need to
be clearly defined because they could be interpreted differently. The instructions for this
application provide a warning that if the application is not completed correctly, it will be denied.
FSA Response: The Department agrees that there may be some confusion for the borrowers
applying for the separation and reconsolidation. The language will be modified to clarify the
instructions.

•

Numbers 19 & 20 cause confusion for divorced couples. What happens if there is no emotional
and/or physical abuse during the relationship, but one party is unwilling to cooperate after the
divorce? What happens if one party refuses to pay their portion of the loan after the divorce
and the person applying for the separation has continued to make the total payments? Because
they cannot certify abuse, does that mean they are unable to separate their loans despite an
uncooperative ex-spouse?
FSA Response: These questions do not relate to the information collection. For guidance related

SpousalConsolidation.DoUsPart! (DoUsPart!)
spousalconsolidation.douspart@gmail.com
www.douspart.org

2

3/11/2024
to divorced couples and the joint versus separate application processes, borrowers should review
the StudentAid.gov website.
•

Numbers 19 & 20 have language about how loans will be separated between the two parties. Per
the previous bullet point, it is unfair for one party paying for both parties to get no credit toward
their portion of the loan, even though they’ve shouldered the burden of paying for both parties.
If these loans cannot be justly and fairly separated based on the many nuances of these
situations, the DoE should consider full discharge. When separation occurs, one party could owe
40%, and the other could owe 60%; however, the party that owes 40% could have been liable to
make monthly payments for both parties following divorce because of an uncooperative exspouse. How will the DoE know who paid what when the NLDS doesn’t track this loan type? Why
should one person who has paid most of the loan get “reset” to pay their entire portion upon
separation? Many group members owe as much or more than their original loan balance. It
seems unfair to separate the loans using the prescribed formula for those who have spent years
paying the whole balance for themselves and their former spouse.
FSA Response: The Joint Consolidation Loan Separation Act does not provide for a co-borrower
of a joint consolidation loan to certify the amount they paid toward the combined debt
compared to the other co-borrower.
No change.

•

The inability to separate these loans individually in divorced situations is unacceptable.
FSA Response: This comment does not relate to the information collection.

Section 5: Repayment Plan Selection
•

The form discusses two payment options, but it’s unclear to the applicant that they must
complete an IDR or SAVE application to choose that payment plan. It must be clearly stated and
bold that applicants must complete that form if they do not want to be placed in a standard
payment plan. The form may also provide a link to complete the additional form.
FSA Response: Section 5 of the application and promissory note details the repayment options
available once the joint consolidation loan is separated and includes a link to the StudentAid.gov
site where borrowers may request an income-driven repayment plan.
No change.

Section 6: Borrower Certifications, Authorizations, and Understandings
•

80% of JSCL holders are in FFELP loans. The impact of this on IDR payments or recounts is not
clear for these borrowers. Will payments made while these loans were held in FFELP loan types
count toward the payment recount? Will these loans be considered for the waivers available to
other loan holders who could consolidate into Direct Loans? The JSCL holders did not and do not
have that ability and should not be penalized for the department's inability to implement a law
that allows consolidation in a Direct Loan.

SpousalConsolidation.DoUsPart! (DoUsPart!)
spousalconsolidation.douspart@gmail.com
www.douspart.org

3

3/11/2024
FSA Response: This comment does not relate to the information collection.
•

If the FFELP IBR/IDR recount will count toward the new Direct Loan, does that mean those
repayment counts will also apply toward PSLF qualifying payments? This is unclear.
FSA Response: This comment does not relate to the information collection.

•

Will loan counts made before the implementation of the PSLF count?
FSA Response: This comment does not relate to the information collection.

•

Regarding IDR/IBR recount and PSLF, how does DoE plan to ensure the person who qualifies for
PSLF gets the correct count applied to their account when the loans are separated?
FSA Response: This comment does not relate to the information collection.

•

Some areas are unclear. Much of the text states, “under certain circumstances,” or “ If you meet
certain conditions;” however, there is no explicit language on what qualifies a person for these
items. The ambiguity leaves too much for interpretation and does not allow borrowers to
understand their rights fully.
FSA Response: The phrase “under certain circumstances” appears in one place in the
application and promissory note, in a paragraph that discusses forbearances, and it is followed
by two specific examples of conditions under which a forbearance may be granted without a
request from the borrower. It would not be feasible to list all the many other circumstances
under which a forbearance may be granted without a request.
The phrase “if you meet certain conditions” also appears just one time, in the section that
discusses loan discharge and forgiveness, and this is followed by descriptions of the available
types of loan discharge and forgiveness and the requirements to qualify. There are certain other
places where similar language is used, such as in the explanations of Public Service Loan
Forgiveness and Teacher Loan Forgiveness. It is not necessary to explain all eligibility
requirements of these loan forgiveness programs in detail in the application and promissory
note, and it would not be practical to do so. That information can easily be obtained from other
sources, such as the Department’s StudentAid.gov website or the borrower’s loan servicer.
No change.

Section 7: Promises

● No comment.

SpousalConsolidation.DoUsPart! (DoUsPart!)
spousalconsolidation.douspart@gmail.com
www.douspart.org

4