Supporting Statement A
30 CFR Part 784: Underground Mining Permit Applications—
Minimum Requirements for Reclamation and Operation Plan
OMB Control Number 1029-0039
Terms of Clearance: None
General Instructions
A completed Supporting Statement A must accompany each request for approval of a collection of information. The Supporting Statement must be prepared in the format described below, and must contain the information specified below. If an item is not applicable, provide a brief explanation. When the question “Does this ICR contain surveys, censuses, or employ statistical methods?” is checked "Yes," then a Supporting Statement B must be completed. OMB reserves the right to require the submission of additional information with respect to any request for approval.
Specific Instructions
Justification
1. Explain the circumstances that make the collection of information necessary. Identify any legal or administrative requirements that necessitate the collection.
2. Indicate how, by whom, and for what purpose the information is to be used. Except for a new collection, indicate the actual use the agency has made of the information received from the current collection. Be specific. If this collection is a form or a questionnaire, every question needs to be justified.
3. Describe whether, and to what extent, the collection of information involves the use of automated, electronic, mechanical, or other technological collection techniques or other forms of information technology, e.g., permitting electronic submission of responses, and the basis for the decision for adopting this means of collection. Also describe any consideration of using information technology to reduce burden and specifically how this collection meets GPEA requirements.
4. Describe efforts to identify duplication. Show specifically why any similar information already available cannot be used or modified for use for the purposes described in Item 2 above.
5. If the collection of information impacts small businesses or other small entities, describe any methods used to minimize burden.
6. Describe the consequence to Federal program or policy activities if the collection is not conducted or is conducted less frequently, as well as any technical or legal obstacles to reducing burden.
7. Explain any special circumstances that would cause an information collection to be conducted in a manner:
* requiring respondents to report information to the agency more often than quarterly;
* requiring respondents to prepare a written response to a collection of information in fewer than 30 days after receipt of it;
* requiring respondents to submit more than an original and two copies of any document;
* requiring respondents to retain records, other than health, medical, government contract, grant-in-aid, or tax records, for more than three years;
* in connection with a statistical survey that is not designed to produce valid and reliable results that can be generalized to the universe of study;
* requiring the use of a statistical data classification that has not been reviewed and approved by OMB;
* that includes a pledge of confidentiality that is not supported by authority established in statute or regulation, that is not supported by disclosure and data security policies that are consistent with the pledge, or which unnecessarily impedes sharing of data with other agencies for compatible confidential use; or
* requiring respondents to submit proprietary trade secrets, or other confidential information, unless the agency can demonstrate that it has instituted procedures to protect the information's confidentiality to the extent permitted by law.
8. If applicable, provide a copy and identify the date and page number of publication in the Federal Register of the agency's notice, required by 5 CFR 1320.8(d), soliciting comments on the information collection prior to submission to OMB. Summarize public comments received in response to that notice and in response to the PRA statement associated with the collection over the past three years, and describe actions taken by the agency in response to these comments. Specifically address comments received on cost and hour burden.
Describe efforts to consult with persons outside the agency to obtain their views on the availability of data, frequency of collection, the clarity of instructions and recordkeeping, disclosure, or reporting format (if any), and on the data elements to be recorded, disclosed, or reported.
Consultation with representatives of those from whom information is to be obtained or those who must compile records should occur at least once every three years — even if the collection of information activity is the same as in prior periods. There may be circumstances that may preclude consultation in a specific situation. These circumstances should be explained.
9. Explain any decision to provide any payment or gift to respondents, other than remuneration of contractors or grantees.
10. Describe any assurance of confidentiality provided to respondents and the basis for the assurance in statute, regulation, or agency policy.
11. Provide additional justification for any questions of a sensitive nature, such as sexual behavior and attitudes, religious beliefs, and other matters that are commonly considered private. This justification should include the reasons why the agency considers the questions necessary, the specific uses to be made of the information, the explanation to be given to persons from whom the information is requested, and any steps to be taken to obtain their consent.
12. Provide estimates of the hour burden of the collection of information. The statement should:
* Indicate the number of respondents, frequency of response, annual hour burden, and an explanation of how the burden was estimated. Unless directed to do so, agencies should not conduct special surveys to obtain information on which to base hour burden estimates. Consultation with a sample (fewer than 10) of potential respondents is desirable. If the hour burden on respondents is expected to vary widely because of differences in activity, size, or complexity, show the range of estimated hour burden, and explain the reasons for the variance. Generally, estimates should not include burden hours for customary and usual business practices.
* If this request for approval covers more than one form, provide separate hour burden estimates for each form and aggregate the hour burdens.
* Provide estimates of annualized cost to respondents for the hour burdens for collections of information, identifying and using appropriate wage rate categories. The cost of contracting out or paying outside parties for information collection activities should not be included here. Instead, this cost should be included under “Annual Cost to Federal Government.”
13. Provide an estimate of the total annual non-hour cost burden to respondents or recordkeepers resulting from the collection of information. (Do not include the cost of any hour burden already reflected in item 12.)
* The cost estimate should be split into two components: (a) a total capital and start-up cost component (annualized over its expected useful life) and (b) a total operation and maintenance and purchase of services component. The estimates should take into account costs associated with generating, maintaining, and disclosing or providing the information (including filing fees paid for form processing). Include descriptions of methods used to estimate major cost factors including system and technology acquisition, expected useful life of capital equipment, the discount rate(s), and the time period over which costs will be incurred. Capital and start-up costs include, among other items, preparations for collecting information such as purchasing computers and software; monitoring, sampling, drilling and testing equipment; and record storage facilities.
* If cost estimates are expected to vary widely, agencies should present ranges of cost burdens and explain the reasons for the variance. The cost of purchasing or contracting out information collection services should be a part of this cost burden estimate. In developing cost burden estimates, agencies may consult with a sample of respondents (fewer than 10), utilize the 60-day pre-OMB submission public comment process and use existing economic or regulatory impact analysis associated with the rulemaking containing the information collection, as appropriate.
* Generally, estimates should not include purchases of equipment or services, or portions thereof, made: (1) prior to October 1, 1995, (2) to achieve regulatory compliance with requirements not associated with the information collection, (3) for reasons other than to provide information or keep records for the government, or (4) as part of customary and usual business or private practices.
14. Provide estimates of annualized cost to the Federal government. Also, provide a description of the method used to estimate cost, which should include quantification of hours, operational expenses (such as equipment, overhead, printing, and support staff), and any other expense that would not have been incurred without this collection of information.
15. Explain the reasons for any program changes or adjustments in hour or cost burden.
16. For collections of information whose results will be published, outline plans for tabulation and publication. Address any complex analytical techniques that will be used. Provide the time schedule for the entire project, including beginning and ending dates of the collection of information, completion of report, publication dates, and other actions.
17. If seeking approval to not display the expiration date for OMB approval of the information collection, explain the reasons that display would be inappropriate.
18. Explain each exception to the topics of the certification statement identified in "Certification for Paperwork Reduction Act Submissions."
Introduction
The Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement (OSMRE), is submitting this information collection clearance package to request authority to collect information and require retention of records under 30 CFR Part 784 - Underground Mining Permit Applications—Minimum Requirements for Reclamation and Operation Plan. Part 784 specifies what an applicant for a permit for an underground coal mine must include in the reclamation plan component of the permit application. OMB previously renewed and approved the collection of information and recordkeeping requirements for this part under control number 1029-0039.
Each section of 30 CFR Part 784 is discussed separately. Because the responses to some items in the instructions for the supporting statement are identical for each section; those responses appear on pages 8 – 10 of this document. Except as otherwise noted in the supporting statements for individual sections, the respondents and potential respondents consist of 45 underground coal mining permit applicants, together with 24 state regulatory authorities.
The tables below summarize the hours for which clearance is requested for Part 784, the total burden hours for each section currently approved by OMB, and the changes we are now requesting. We are requesting 14,906 burden hours, an increase of 2,116 hours from the currently approved level of 12,790 hours. We are also seeking an increase in non-wage cost burden of $62,228, to a new total of $439,110. The increases are a result of adjustments in the number of responses.
SUMMARY FOR 30 CFR PART 784
Section |
Industry Responses |
Industry Hours per Response |
State Responses |
State Hours per Response |
Total Hours Requested |
Currently Approved Burden Hours |
Changes to Burden Hours |
784.11 |
45 |
4 |
44 |
3 |
312 |
270 |
42 |
.12 |
6 |
6 |
5 |
2.25 |
47 |
47 |
0 |
.13 |
45 |
53 |
44 |
4.5 |
2,583 |
2,238 |
345 |
.14 |
45 |
40 |
44 |
8.75 |
2,185 |
1,893 |
292 |
.15 |
45 |
6 |
44 |
1 |
314 |
272 |
42 |
.16 |
45 |
16 |
44 |
10 |
1,160 |
1,004 |
156 |
.17 |
1 |
6 |
1 |
5 |
11 |
11 |
0 |
.18 |
18 |
8 |
17 |
2 |
178 |
178 |
0 |
.19 |
34 |
9 |
33 |
12 |
702 |
429 |
273 |
.20 |
45 |
12 |
44 |
4 |
716 |
620 |
96 |
.21 |
45 |
4 |
44 |
8 |
532 |
460 |
72 |
.22 |
45 |
24 |
44 |
6 |
1,344 |
1,164 |
180 |
.23 |
45 |
40 |
44 |
7.5 |
2,130 |
1,845 |
285 |
.24 |
45 |
20 |
44 |
4.5 |
1,098 |
951 |
147 |
.25 |
21 |
6 |
20 |
4 |
206 |
206 |
0 |
.29 |
45 |
16 |
44 |
5 |
940 |
814 |
126 |
.30 |
45 |
8 |
44 |
2 |
448 |
388 |
60 |
TOTALS |
|
|
|
|
14,906 |
12,790 |
2,116 |
SUMMARY OF NON-WAGE COSTS FOR 30 CFR PART 784
Section |
Currently Approved Non-Wage Costs ($) |
Requested Non-Wage Costs ($) |
Changes to Non-Wage Costs ($) |
784.11 |
3,900 |
4,500 |
600 |
784.12 |
600 |
600 |
0 |
784.13 |
19,500 |
22,500 |
3,000 |
784.14 |
97,500 |
112,500 |
15,000 |
784.15 |
780 |
900 |
120 |
784.16 |
6,552 |
7,560 |
1,008 |
784.17 |
550 |
550 |
0 |
784.18 |
900 |
900 |
0 |
784.19 |
10,500 |
17,000 |
6,500 |
784.20 |
19,500 |
22,500 |
3,000 |
784.21 |
7,800 |
9,000 |
1,200 |
784.22 |
195,000 |
225,000 |
30,000 |
784.23 |
3,900 |
4,500 |
600 |
784.24 |
1,950 |
2,250 |
300 |
784.25 |
2,100 |
2,100 |
0 |
784.29 |
1,950 |
2,250 |
300 |
784.30 |
3,900 |
4,500 |
600 |
TOTALS |
376,882 |
439,110 |
62,228 |
List of Items with Identical Responses
A. Justification
3. At the discretion of the regulatory authority, persons may submit responses electronically to the extent that both parties have the requisite technical capability. Further, permit applicants have been increasingly using electronic means to prepare their permit applications using word processing, AutoCAD and GPS software applications. Several states, such as Kentucky and Virginia, receive 90% of their permit applications electronically. Other states are not yet prepared to receive applications electronically because of other priorities or the limited size of their program. We estimate that on a national basis, 75% of all permit applications are submitted by electronic means. We hope that this figure will improve over time as more states and permit applicants realize the time and cost savings associated with electronic submissions.
4. The information requested under 30 CFR Part 784 is collected infrequently (generally only once, at the time that a person applies for a permit). Therefore, duplication is minimal to nonexistent. When submitting an application for a permit revision, permittees may cross-reference relevant materials previously submitted in a permit application.
5. There are no special provisions for small organizations. While small operators may be eligible for financial assistance under the Small Operators Assistance Program (SOAP), Congress has not appropriated money for that program in recent years.
6. A reduction in the frequency of collection is not possible because the information requested under 30 CFR Part 784 is collected only once for each site.
7. No collection of information under 30 CFR Part 784 is inconsistent with the guidelines at 5 CFR 1320.5(d)(2) as summarized in the instructions for this item of the supporting statement.
8. To determine the burden that would be placed on respondents by the revisions to 30 CFR Part 784, OSMRE relied on information supplied by our Knoxville Field Office, which processes permit applications for lands for which OSMRE is the regulatory authority in the Appalachian Region, and contacted the following state regulatory authorities and a mining consulting firm that prepares mining permit applications. We supplied a concise description of the proposed revisions along with a request for input on the associated information collection requirements and any other comments they wished to make regarding the clarity of the rules and potential burdens.
Charles Sturey
West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection
601 57th St. Charleston,
WV 25304
Phone: (304) 926-0490
Email: charles.s.sturey@wv.gov
Tim Browning
Department of Mines, Minerals and Energy
Division of Mine Land Reclamation
3405 Mountain Empire Rd
Big Stone Gap, VA 24219
Phone: (434-523-8156)
Email: Tinothy.Browning@dmme.virginia.gov.
Roger Jones
Red River Coal
6999
Polk Rd, Norton, VA 24273
(276) 679-1400
Email: rogerjones@redrivercoal.com
Mark Stinnett
Division of Natural Resources
Kentucky Division of Mine Permits
#2 Hudson Hollow Rd
Frankfort. KY 40601
502-564-6940
Mark,Stinnett@ky.gov
The persons listed above had no concerns or complaints to the requirements of 30 CFR 784.11 thru .30.
On September 4, 2014, OSMRE published in the Federal Register (79 FR 52750) a notice requesting comments from the public regarding the need for the collection of information, the accuracy of the burden estimate, ways to enhance the information collection, and ways to minimize the burden on respondents. This notice gave the public 60 days in which to comment. However, no comments were received.
9. Not applicable. OSMRE and state regulatory authorities provide no payments or gifts to respondents except for grants to states authorized by law.
10. The permit applicant has the right to request confidentiality for certain information, for example, analyses of the chemical and physical properties of the coal to be mined. Sections 507(b)(17), 508(a)(12), and 508(b) of SMCRA require that certain types of permit application information be kept confidential if requested by the permit applicant and approved by the regulatory authority. The Archeological Resources Protection Act of 1979, 16 U.S.C. 470, requires that information on the nature and location of archeological resources on public lands and Indian lands be kept confidential.
11. Not applicable. Sensitive questions are not asked.
12. The total number of respondents was derived from OSMRE’s annual reports for evaluation year 2013. Burden hour estimates were derived from discussions with respondents identified in item 8.
OSMRE has estimated wage costs for respondents: industry and state regulatory employees. OSMRE has derived these wages from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) websites at (http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/naics4_212100.htm for industry wages, and http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/naics4_999200.htm for state employee wages. Benefits are included in these wage calculations using a rate of 1.4 of the salary for industry personnel and 1.5 for state employees per the BLS news release USDL-14-1075, EMPLOYER COSTS FOR EMPLOYEE COMPENSATION—MARCH 2014, dated June 11, 2014 (http://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/ecec.pdf).
14. Wage costs for OSMRE employees are calculated based on the Office of Personnel Management website, http://www.opm.gov/policy-data-oversight/pay-leave/salaries-wages/salary-tables/pdf/2014/RUS_h.pdf. Salaries for Federal employees in this section include a benefits rate of 1.5 per the BLS news release USDL-14-1075, EMPLOYER COSTS FOR EMPLOYEE COMPENSATION—MARCH 2014, dated June 11, 2014 (http://www.bls.gov/news.release/pdf/ecec.pdf).
16. Not applicable. OSMRE has no plans to publish the information collected.
17. Not applicable. OSMRE is not seeking a waiver from the requirement to display the expiration date of the OMB approval of the information collection.
18. Not applicable. There are no exceptions to the certification statement, "Certification for Paperwork Reduction Act Submissions."
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.11
A. Justification
1. Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.11 reflect this requirement. The underlying statutory provisions upon which the rule is based include section 507(b)(7), which requires a description of the type and method of coal mining operation that exists or is proposed, the engineering techniques proposed or used, and the equipment used or proposed to be used in the mining operation, and section 508(a)(5), which requires submission of the engineering techniques to be used in mining and reclamation and a description of the major equipment to be used.
2. Paragraph (a) requires a narrative description of the mining methods, engineering techniques, and major equipment planned for use in the operation, and a description of the anticipated production of the mine.
Paragraph (b) requires a narrative description of the planned use of certain listed facilities, including construction, modification, maintenance, and removal of such facilities.
This information is necessary to enable the regulatory authority to evaluate the cumulative impact of the proposed operations on the resources of the area, including the hydrologic balance, land, vegetation, and fish and wildlife. In addition, this information will aid the regulatory authority in determining whether the applicant can meet the applicable performance standards of this Chapter.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the 24 state regulatory authorities annually receive approximately 45 new permit applications for underground mines (44 by states and one by us), all of which must include the information required by 30 CFR 784.11. Each applicant requires 4 hours to collect this information. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 180 hours (45 applications x 4 hours per application).
The total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review this portion of the permit application is approximately 132 hours (44 permit applications received by state regulatory authorities x 3 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 312 hours (180 hours for permit applicants + 132 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Administrative Support |
1 |
22.83 |
22.83 |
Engineering Technician |
2 |
39.09 |
78.18 |
Mining Engineer |
1 |
58.60 |
58.60 |
Total |
4 |
|
159.61 |
Therefore, the estimated total annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.11 is $160 (rounded). The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $160 x 45 permits = $7,200.
In addition, it takes 3 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.11 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 3 hours = $99.06. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $99.06 x 44 permit applications = $4,359.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $7,200 for industry + $4,359 for state regulatory authorities = $11,559.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents:
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs.
Non-labor cost information was provided by the engineering companies and includes permit application costs for items such as equipment, copying, travel to the mine site and other locations for data collection, newspaper publications, laboratory analysis, and postage. This cost is $100 per application, or $4,500 ($100 x 45 applications) for all applicants.
b. Operation, Maintenance and Services
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimate of Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of State program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of State compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.11 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 40 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $2,264 (rounded).
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive 1 application for a new underground mine permit for lands and operations for which OSMRE is the regulatory authority, requiring 7 hours to review. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour as referenced above, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review the narrative explaining construction, maintenance and use of facilities will be $396 (1 application x 7 hours per finding x $56.61 per hour).
Total Federal Cost
$ 2,264 Oversight
+ $ 396 Federal Programs
$ 2,660 Total Federal Cost
There are currently 270 hours approved for this section. We anticipate an adjustment that will increase the burden by 42 hours because of an estimated increase in the number of respondents. The burden will change as follows:
270 hours currently approved
+ 42 hours due to an adjustment
312 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase of $600 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in respondents for a new total of $4,500.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.12
A. Justification.
1. Section 507(b)(13) of SMCRA requires the permit applicant to provide a description of each existing structure proposed to be used in the mining or reclamation operation and a compliance plan for structures proposed to be modified or constructed for use in the operation. Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA, including those of section 507(b)(13), are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines.
2. The regulatory authority uses the information collected under this section to determine if existing structures can comply with the performance standards in Part 817 of our regulations, and, if not, what modifications are needed.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us). Based on contacts with state agencies and permit applicants, we estimate that approximately 13% (6) of those permit applications propose to use existing structures and therefore must supply this information, which requires an estimated 6 hours to prepare. Therefore, the total annual burden on permit applicants for compliance with this section is 36 hours (6 permit applications x 6 hours per application).
The total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review this portion of the permit application is approximately 11 hours (5 permit applications received by state regulatory authorities x 2.25 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 47 hours (36 hours for permit applicants + 11 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Administrative Support |
1 |
22.83 |
22.83 |
Engineering Technician |
4 |
39.09 |
156.36 |
Mining Engineer |
1 |
58.60 |
58.60 |
Total |
6 |
|
237.79 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.12 is $238 (rounded). The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $238 x 6 permits = $1,428.
In addition, it takes 2.25 hours for each State regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for a state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.12 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 2.25 hours = $74.30. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $74.30 x 5 permit applications = $372.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $1,428 for industry + $372 for state regulatory authorities = $1,800.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents.
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs.
Non-labor cost information was provided by the engineering companies and include permit applications costs for items such as equipment, copying, travel to the mine site and other locations for data collection, newspaper publications, laboratory analyzes, and postage. This cost is $100 per respondent. The total costs for all permit applicants would be $600 (6 applications x $100 per application).
b. Operation, Maintenance and Services.
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimate of Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of State compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.12 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 20 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $1,132.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive 1 application for an underground permit for lands and operations for which OSMRE is the regulatory authority, requiring 9 hours to review. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour as referenced above, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review the narrative on existing structures will be $509 (1 application x 9 hours per review x $56.61 per hour).
Total Federal Cost
$ 1,132 Oversight
+ $ 509 Federal Programs
$ 1,641 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 47 hours approved for this section. There is no change to the current approved burden hours.
47 hours currently approved
- 0 hours due to an adjustment
47 hours requested
This request will also result in the same burden of $600 for non-wage costs.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See
List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.13
A. Justification.
1. Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. Sections 507(d) and 508(a) of SMCRA requires that each permit application include a reclamation plan containing certain information. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.13 implement this requirement for underground mines.
2. Detailed information is required to enable the regulatory authority to determine whether the proposed mining operation will be conducted in compliance with the performance standards contained in Subchapter K of these regulations and to make the findings required to issue a permit. The required information includes a detailed timetable for the completion of each major step in the reclamation plan and a detailed estimate of the cost of reclamation together with supporting calculations, and is necessary for the regulatory authority to determine the amount of the bond. Information includes plans for spoil handling, soil replacement, revegetation, conservation of the coal resource, acid/toxic material handling, combustible material handling, sealed or managed mine openings complying with the Clean Air Act and the Clean Water Act.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us), all of which must include the information required by this section. Each applicant requires 53 hours to prepare this information. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 2,385 hours (45 applications x 53 hours per application).
The total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review this portion of the permit application is approximately 198 hours (44 permit applications received by state regulatory authorities x 4.5 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 2,583 (2,385 hours for permit applicants + 198 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Administrative Support |
5 |
22.83 |
114.15 |
Environmental Technician |
30 |
39.09 |
1,172.70 |
Environmental Engineer |
15 |
54.42 |
816.30 |
Operations Manager |
3 |
81.63 |
244.89 |
Total |
53 |
|
$2,348.04 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.13 is $2,348 (rounded). The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $2,348 x 45 permits = $105,660.
In addition, it takes 4.5 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.13 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 4.5 hours = $149. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $149 x 44 permit applications = $6,556.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $105,660 for industry + $6,556 for State regulatory authorities = $112,216.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents:
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs.
Non-labor cost information was provided by the engineering companies and include permit application costs for items such as equipment, copying, travel to the mine site and other locations for data collection, newspaper publications, laboratory analyzes, and postage. This cost is $500 per respondent. The total costs for all applicants would be $22,500 (45 applications x $500 per application).
b. Operation, Maintenance and Services.
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimate of Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of State compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.13 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 60 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $3,397.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive 1 application for an underground permit for lands and operations for which OSMRE is the regulatory authority, requiring 10 hours to review. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour as referenced above, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review the narrative on existing structures will be $566 (1 application x 10 hours per review x $56.61 per hour).
Total Federal Cost
$ 3,397 Oversight
+ $ 566 Federal Programs
$ 3,963 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 2,238 hours approved for this section. We anticipate an increase in the number of applications. The adjustment will increase the burden by 345 hours. The burden will change as follows:
2,238 hours currently approved
+ 345 hours due to an adjustment
2,583 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase reduction of $3,000 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in the number of respondents, for a new total of $22,500.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.14
A. Justification.
1. Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.14 reflect this requirement. Section 507(b)(11) of SMCRA requires that the application include a determination of the probably hydrologic consequences of the proposed operations. Section 508(a)(13) of SMCRA requires that the application include a detailed description of the measures to be taken to protect the quality and quantity of surface and ground water systems and the rights of water users. Section 517(b)(2) of SMCRA requires that the permittee monitor both surface and ground water systems. Collection and analysis of the baseline hydrologic information required by 30 CFR 784.14 is an integral element of meeting those statutory requirements and determining the effects of mining and reclamation. Collection of this information is necessary to predict whether mining may have adverse impacts on the hydrologic balance and, if so, to develop plans for remedial and restorative measures.
2. The permit applicant uses the information collected under 30 CFR 784.14 to develop the determination of the probable hydrologic consequences of the proposed operation, as required by the statute, and to provide a baseline for the monitoring program also required by the statute. The regulatory authority uses the information to assist in evaluating the probable impacts of the operation on surface and ground water systems and in preparing the cumulative hydrologic impact assessment, as well as determining whether the operation has been designed to meet the hydrologic protection requirements of the statute.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us), all of which must include the information required by this section. Each applicant requires 40 hours to prepare this information, based on discussions with industry representatives. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 1,800 hours (45 applications x 40 hours per application).
The total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review this portion of the permit application is approximately 385 hours (44 permit applications received by state regulatory authorities x 8.75 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 2,185 hours (1,800 hours for permit applicants + 385 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Administrative Support |
3 |
22.83 |
68.49 |
Earth Drillers |
20 |
32.91 |
658.20 |
Geological Engineer |
16 |
58.60 |
937.60 |
Operations Manager |
1 |
81.63 |
81.63 |
Total |
40 |
|
$1,745.92 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.14 is $1,746. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $1,746 x 45 permits = $78,570.
In addition, it takes 8.75 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.14 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 8.75 hours = $289. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $295 x 44 permit applications = $12,716.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $78,570 for industry + $12,716 for State regulatory authorities = $91,286.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents:
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs.
Non-labor costs for each application are $2,500, or a total cost of $112,500 for all permit applicants (45 applications x $2,500 per application). The non-labor costs were provided by the engineering companies and include permit application costs for items such as equipment, copying, travel to the mine site and other locations for data collection, newspaper publications, laboratory analysis, and postage.
b. Operation, Maintenance and Services.
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimate of Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of State compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.14 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 80 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $4,529.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive 1 application for a new permit where OSMRE is the regulatory authority, requiring 12 hours to review. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review the plan will be $679 (1 plan x 12 hours per review x $56.61 per hour).
Total Federal Cost
$ 4,529 Oversight
+ $ 679 Federal Programs
$ 5,208 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 1,893 hours approved for this section. We anticipate an increase in applications. The adjustment will increase the burden by 292 hours. The burden will change as follows:
1,893 hours currently approved
+ 292 hours due to an adjustment
2,185 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase of $15,000 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in respondents, for a new total of $112,500.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.15
A. Justification.
1. Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.15 reflect this requirement. Section 784.15 requires permit applicants to provide a description of the current land use, its productivity, the proposed postmining land use, and documentation regarding comments received from the landowners and state and local governments concerning the postmining land use. Section 784.15 implements subsections (a)(2)(A), (B), and (C) and (a)(3) and (4) of section 508 of SMCRA with respect to underground mines.
2. The regulatory authority uses the information required in section 784.15 in making decisions on proposed postmining land uses and provides a baseline for determination of revegetation success. Failure to submit this information would hamper assessment of reclamation success.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us), all of which must include the information required by this section. Each applicant requires 6 hours to prepare this information. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 270 hours (45 applications x 6 hours per application).
The burden for state regulatory authorities to review this portion of the permit application is approximately one hour, or 44 hours to review all underground permit applications (44 permit applications received by state regulatory authorities x 1 hour per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 314 hours (270 hours for permit applicants + 44 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Administrative Support |
.5 |
22.83 |
11.42 |
Environmental Technician |
4 |
39.09 |
156.36 |
Environmental Engineer |
1 |
54.42 |
54.42 |
Operations Manager |
.5 |
81.63 |
40.82 |
Total |
6 |
|
263.02 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.15 is $263. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $263 x 45 permits = $11,835.
In addition, it takes 1 hour for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.15 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 1 hour = $33. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $33 x 44 permit applications = $1,452.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $11,835 for industry + $1,452 for state regulatory authorities = $13,287.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents.
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $20, or a total cost of $900 for all applicants (45 applications x $20 per application).
b. Operation, Maintenance and Services:
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimate of Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of State compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.15 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 12 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $679.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive 1 application for a new permit where OSMRE is the regulatory authority, requiring 2 hours to review. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review the plan will be $113 (1 plan x 2 hours per review x $56.61 per hour).
Total Federal Cost
$ 679 Oversight
+ $ 113 Federal Programs
$ 792 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 272 hours approved for this section. We anticipate an increase in the number of applications. The adjustment will increase the burden by 42 hours. The burden will change as follows:
272 hours currently approved
+ 42 hours due to an adjustment
314 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase of $120 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in respondents, for a new total of $900.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Sections 784.16
A. Justification.
1. This section contains design and other permit application requirements for siltation structures, impoundments, and refuse piles. Sections 507(b)(14) and 516(b)(4) and (5) of SMCRA provide authority for these requirements. Section 516(d) of SMCRA states that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.16 reflect this requirement.
2. Both permit applicants and SMCRA regulatory authorities use the information required by this rule to ensure that siltation structures, impoundments, and refuse piles are designed to protect safety, property, and the environment.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden.
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents.
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us), all of which must include the information required by this section. Based on our experience, we estimate that each application for an underground mine permit will include one refuse pile, in part because our 1983 rule revisions classify underground development waste as coal mine waste (refuse). Each applicant will need 16 hours to prepare the information required by 30 CFR 784.16 for siltation structures, impoundments, and refuse piles for each permit application. This unit burden includes the burden for design certifications for refuse piles.
We estimate that the total annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section will be 720 hours (45 applications x 16 hours per application).
The burden for state regulatory authorities to review the information submitted under this section would require 10 hours. Therefore, we estimate that the total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review this information for 30 CFR 784.16 in its entirety would be 440 hours (44 permit applications received by state regulatory authorities x 10 hours per application).
We estimate that the total annual burden for all respondents will be 1,160 (720 hours for permit applicants + 440 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents.
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Administrative Support |
1 |
22.83 |
22.83 |
Engineering Technician |
4 |
39.09 |
156.36 |
Mining Engineer |
10 |
58.60 |
586.00 |
Operations Manager |
1 |
81.63 |
81.63 |
Total |
16 |
|
846.82 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.16 is $847. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $847 x 45 permits = $38,115.
In addition, it takes 10 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.16 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 10 hours = $330. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $330 x 44 permit applications = $14,520.
Therefore, we estimate that the total wage cost to all respondents is $38,115 for industry + $14,520 for state regulatory authorities = $52,635.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents:
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $168, which translates to a total cost of $7,560 for all applicants (45 applications x $168 per application).
b. Operation, Maintenance, and Services:
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimate of Costs to the Federal Government
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of State compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.16 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 60 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $3,397.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive 1 application for a new permit where OSMRE is the regulatory authority. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour for 10 hours to review this section of the application, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review the plan will be $566 (1 application x $56.61 x 10 hours).
Total Federal Cost
$ 3,397 Oversight
+ $ 566 Federal Programs
$ 3,963 Total Federal Cost
There are currently 1,004 hours approved for this section. We anticipate that the burden will increase by 156 hours due to an adjustment in responses. Therefore the burden will change as shown below:
1,004 hours currently approved
+ 156 hours due to an adjustment
1,160 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase of $1,008 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in respondents, for a new total of $7,560.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.17
A. Justification
1. Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.17 reflect this requirement. They require the permit applicant to describe measures that will be taken as part of the proposed surface coal mining operations to prevent or minimize adverse impacts to publicly owned parks and places listed on the National Register of Historic Places, as required by section 522(e)(3) of SMCRA.
2. This information will enable the regulatory authority to determine whether the operation has been designed to meet the requirements of section 522(e)(3) of SMCRA, which prohibits surface coal mining operations that will have adverse effects on publicly owned parks or places listed on the National Register of Historic Places unless the agency with jurisdiction over the park or place grants joint approval or the applicant has valid existing rights.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us). Based on previous studies, we estimate that, on an annual basis, no more than one application for an underground mine will include the information required by this section. We estimate that preparing that information will require 6 hours. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 6 hours (1 application x 6 hours per application).
The total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review this portion of the permit application is approximately 5 hours (1 permit application x 5 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 11 hours (6 hours for permit applicants + 5 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Environmental Technician |
5 |
39.09 |
195.45 |
Operations Manager |
1 |
81.63 |
81.63 |
Total |
6 |
|
277.08 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.17 is $277. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $277 x 1 permit = $277.
In addition, it takes 5 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for the state regulatory authority to review §784.17 of the permit application is $33.02 per hour x 5 hours = $165. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $165 x 1 permit application = $165.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $277 for industry + $165 for state regulatory authorities = $442.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents.
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $550, or a total non-labor cost of $550 for the one permit applicant anticipated each year.
b. Operation, Maintenance and Services:
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimate of Costs to the Federal Government.
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of state compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.17 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. OSMRE assumes that we will conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year and that each review requires an average of 3 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $170.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will not receive an application which contains information required under section 784.17. However, should we receive an application that includes this information, we estimate that 5 hours will be required to review that application to ensure compliance with section 784.17. Using one application per year as a placeholder, the cost of reviewing that application would be $283 (1 application x 5 hours per application x $56.61 per hour).
Total Federal Cost
$ 170 Oversight
+ $ 283 Federal Programs
$ 453 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 11 hours approved for this section. We anticipate no changes to this section in burden hours or non-wage costs.
hours currently approved
- 0 hours changed
11 hours requested
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.18
A. Justification.
Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.18, which require that the permit application include a description of the measures to be taken to protect the interests of the public and affected landowners when mining is to take place within 100 feet of a public road or when a public road is to be relocated, reflect this requirement. The regulations implement, in part, section 522(e)(5) of the Act, which requires that the regulatory authority ensure the protection of the public and affected landowners in these situations.
2. The regulatory authority uses the information collected under this section to fulfill its responsibilities to protect the public and affected landowners under section 522(e)(5) of SMCRA.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us). Based on prior studies, we estimate that the requirements of this section apply to 41% (18) of those applications. We also estimate that it requires 8 hours to complete this portion of the application. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 144 hours (18 applications x 8 hours per application).
The total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review this portion of the permit application is approximately 34 hours (17 permit applications containing this information received by state regulatory authorities x 2 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 178 hours (144 hours for permit applicants + 34 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Mining Engineer |
7 |
58.60 |
410.20 |
Operations Manager |
1 |
81.63 |
81.63 |
Total |
8 |
|
491.83 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.18 is $491.83. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $491.83 x 18 applications = $8,853.
In addition, it takes 2 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.18 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 2 hours = $66.04. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $66.04 x 17 permit applications = $1,123.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $8,853 for industry + $1,123 for state regulatory authorities = $9,976.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $50, which translates to a total cost of $900 for all applicants (18 applications x $50 per application).
b. Operation, Maintenance, and Services.
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimate of Costs to the Federal Government
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of state compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.18 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 8 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $453.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive 1 application for a new permit where OSMRE is the regulatory authority. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review the 1 plan at 2 hours per review will be $113 (1 application x $56.61 x 2 hours).
Total Federal Cost
$ 453 Oversight
+ $ 113 Federal Programs
$ 566 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 178 hours approved for this section. We anticipate no changes to the burden hours or non-wage costs to this section.
178 hours currently approved
- 0 hours due to an adjustment
178 hours requested
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.19
A. Justification.
1. Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.19, which establish permit application requirements for the disposal of excess spoil from underground mines, reflect this requirement. Section 508(a)(5) of SMCRA requires that the permit application include a statement of the engineering techniques to be used in mining and reclamation, as well as a description of how the operation will comply with each requirement of section 515. Paragraph (b)(22) of section 515 addresses the disposal of excess spoil.
2. The regulatory authority uses the geotechnical investigation and fill design requirements of this section to ensure that excess spoil is disposed of safely in a stable manner with a minimum of adverse environmental impacts.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (45 by the states and one by us), of which we estimate that 75% (34) will include an excess spoil fill and therefore must include the information required by this section. A permit applicant will need a total of 9 hours to collect the information required under 30 CFR 784.19. Therefore, the total annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section is 306 hours (34 applications x 9 hours per application).
The burden for state regulatory authorities to review the information submitted under this section would average 12 hours per application. We estimate that the total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review permit applications under 30 CFR 784.19 will be 396 hours (33 permit applications received by state regulatory authorities with proposed excess spoil fills x 12 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 702 hours (306 hours for permit applicants + 396 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Mining Engineer |
8 |
58.60 |
468.8 |
Operations Manager |
1 |
81.63 |
81.63 |
Total |
9 |
|
550.43 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.19 is $550. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $550 x 34 permits = $18,700.
In addition, it takes 12 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.19 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 12 hours = $396. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $396 x 33 permit applications = $13,068.
Therefore, we estimate that the total wage cost to all respondents is $18,700 for industry + $13,068 for state regulatory authorities = $31,768.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents.
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $500, and a total cost of $17,000 for all applicants (34 applications x $500 per application).
b. Operation, Maintenance, and Services:
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimate of Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of state compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.19 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 40 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $2,264.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive 1 application for a new permit where OSMRE is the regulatory authority. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour for 12 hours to review this section of the application, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review this section will be $679 (1 application x $56.61 x 12 hours).
Total Federal Cost
$ 2,264 Oversight
+ $ 679 Federal Programs
$ 2,943 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 429 hours approved for this section. Due to an increase in applications, we anticipate a burden change as follows:
429 hours currently approved
+ 273 hours due to an adjustment
702 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase of $6,500 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in respondents, for a new total of $17,000.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.20
A. Justification.
1. Section 516(b)(1) of SMCRA requires each operator of an underground mine to prevent subsidence that would cause material damage, to the extent technologically and economically feasible. Our regulations at 30 CFR 784.20 contain permitting requirements, including preparation of a subsidence control plan, related to this performance standard. Those regulations also contain permitting requirements intended to support the implementation of section 720 of SMCRA, which requires the correction of subsidence-related material damage to certain structures and the replacement of domestic water supplies adversely impacted by underground mining operations.
2. The regulatory authority uses the preliminary survey information provided under 30 CFR 784.20 to determine whether a subsidence control plan is needed. It also may use the information provided under this section to evaluate future claims of subsidence damage. The subsidence control plan is the mechanism by which the regulatory authority requires compliance with the directive in section 516(b)(1) of the Act that operators "adopt measures consistent with known technology in order to prevent subsidence causing material damage to the extent technologically and economically feasible."
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us), all of which include at least some of the information required by 30 CFR 784.20. Each applicant requires an average of 12 hours to prepare this information. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 540 hours (45 applications per year x 12 hours per application).
The burden for state regulatory authorities to review the information submitted under this section would average 4 hours per application. We estimate that the total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review permit applications under 30 CFR 784.20 will be 176 hours (44 permit applications approved by state regulatory authorities per year x 4 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 716 hours (540 hours for permit applicants + 176 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Mining Engineer |
10 |
58.60 |
586.00 |
Operations Manager |
2 |
81.63 |
163.26 |
Total |
12 |
|
749.26 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.20 is $749. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $749 x 45 permits = $33,705.
In addition, it takes 4 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.20 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 4 hours = $132. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $132 x 44 permit applications = $5,812.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $39,517 for industry + $5,812 for state regulatory authorities = $33,554.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents.
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $500, or a total annual cost of $22,500 for all applicants (45 applications per year x $500 per application).
b. Operation, Maintenance, and Services:
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimated Costs to the Federal Government
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of state compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.20 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 24 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $1,359.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive 1 application for a new permit where OSMRE is the regulatory authority. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour for 4 hours to review this section of the application, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review this section will be $226 (1 application x $56.61 x 4 hours).
Total Federal Cost
$ 1,359 Oversight
+ $ 226 Federal Programs
$ 1,585 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 620 hours approved for this section. The burden will increase because of an adjustment in the number of applications. The new burden is as follows:
620 hours currently approved
+ 96 hours due to an adjustment
716 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase $3,000 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in respondents, for a new total of $22,500.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.21
A. Justification.
1. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.21 require that each application for an underground mine include baseline fish and wildlife resource information for the proposed permit and adjacent areas. They also require submission of a fish and wildlife protection and enhancement plan. Those requirements are intended to assist implementation of section 516(b)(11) of SMCRA, which requires that coal mining operations be conducted to minimize disturbances and adverse impacts to fish, wildlife, and related environmental values and achieve enhancement where applicable.
2. The regulatory authority uses the information provided under 30 CFR 784.21 to ensure that the operation is designed meet the requirements of section 516(b)(11) of SMCRA to minimize disturbance and adverse impacts on fish, wildlife and related environmental values to the extent possible using the best technology currently available.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us), all of which must include the information required by this section. Each applicant requires 4 hours to prepare this information. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 180 hours (45 applications x 4 hours per application).
The burden for state regulatory authorities to review the information submitted under this section would average 8 hours per application. We estimate that the total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review permit applications under 30 CFR 784.21 will be 352 hours (44 permit applications approved by state regulatory authorities per year x 8 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 532 hours (180 hours for permit applicants + 352 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Administrative Support |
.5 |
22.83 |
11.42 |
Environmental Technician |
3 |
39.09 |
117.27 |
Environmental Engineer |
.5 |
54.42 |
27.21 |
Total |
4 |
|
155.90 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.21 is $156. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $156 x 45 permits = $7,020.
In addition, it takes 8 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.21 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 8 hours = $264. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $264 x 44 permit applications = $11,616.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $7,020 for industry + $11,616 for state regulatory authorities = $18,636.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents.
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $200, which translates to a total cost of $9,000 for all applicants (45 applications x $200 per application).
b. Operations, Maintenance and Services:
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimated Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of state compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.21 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 12 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits).
The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $679.
Federal Programs: Based upon data collected in 2013, OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive 1 application for a new permit where OSMRE is the regulatory authority. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour for 4 hours to review this section of the application, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review this section will be $226 (1 application x $56.61 x 4 hours).
Total Federal Cost
$ 679 Oversight
+ $ 226 Federal Programs
$ 905 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 460 hours approved for this section. This request will increase the burden by 72 hours because of a change in applications. The burden will change as follows:
460 hours currently approved
- 72 hours due to an adjustment
532 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase of $1,200 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in respondents, for a new total of $9,000.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.22
A. Justification.
1. Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.22, which require that the permit application include various geologic data, reflect this requirement. Sections 507(b)(11), (14) and (15) and 508(a)(13) of SMCRA require collection and analysis of geologic information to determine the probable hydrologic consequences of the proposed mining operations and any potentially acid- or toxic-forming substances that may affect the quality of surface waters or groundwater systems.
2. The regulatory authority uses the information submitted under 30 CFR 784.22 to evaluate the adequacy of the hydrologic reclamation plan for the proposed operation, to determine whether a toxic materials handling plan is needed, to ascertain whether discharge treatment will be needed and whether those discharges will cease after mining and reclamation, to determine whether reclamation is feasible, and prepare the cumulative hydrologic impact assessment required by SMCRA for issuance of a permit.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us), all of which must include the information required by this section. Each applicant requires 24 hours to prepare this information. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 1,080 hours (45 applications x 24 hours per application).
The burden for state regulatory authorities to review the information submitted under this section would average 6 hours per application. We estimate that the total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review permit applications under 30 CFR 784.22 will be 264 hours (44 permit applications approved by state regulatory authorities per year x 6 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 1,344 (1,080 hours for permit applicants + 264 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Administrative Support |
1 |
22.83 |
22.83 |
Samplers |
16 |
31.25 |
500.00 |
Geological Engineer |
6 |
58.60 |
351.6 |
Operations Manager |
1 |
81.63 |
81.63 |
Total |
24 |
|
956.06 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.22 is $956. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $956 x 45 permits = $43,020.
In addition, it takes 6 hours for each State regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.22 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 6 hours = $198. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $198 x 44 permit applications = $8,712.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $43,020 for industry + $8,712 for state regulatory authorities = $51,732.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents.
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $5,000 for this section, which translates to a total cost of $225,000 for all applicants (45 applications x $5,000 per application).
b. Operations, Maintenance, and Services:
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimate of Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of state compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.22 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 12 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $679.
Federal Programs: Based upon data collected in 2013, OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive one underground application for a new permit where OSMRE is the regulatory authority, requiring 6 hours to review. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour for 6 hours to review this section of the application, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review this section will be $340 (1 application x $56.61 x 6 hours).
Total Federal Cost
$ 679 Oversight
+ $ 340 Federal Programs
$ 1,019 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 1,164 hours approved for this section. This request will increase the burden estimate for this section by 185 hours. The burden will change as follows:
1,164 hours currently approved
+ 185 hours due to an adjustment
1,349 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase of $30,000 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in respondents, for a new total of $225,000.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.23
A. Justification.
1. Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.23 reflect this requirement. Those regulations, like sections 507(b)(13) and (14) of SMCRA, require each applicant to submit maps, plans, and cross-sections of the proposed permit area and the adjacent area.
2. The regulatory authority uses the maps, cross-sections, and plans submitted with the application to ensure that the operation has been located and designed in accordance with the requirements of SMCRA.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us), all of which must include the information required by this section. Each applicant requires 40 hours to prepare this information. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 1,800 hours (45 applications x 40 hours per application).
The burden for state regulatory authorities to review the information submitted under this section would average 7.5 hours per application. We estimate that the total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review permit applications under 30 CFR 784.23 will be 330 hours (44 permit applications received by state regulatory authorities x 7.5 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 2,130 hours (1,800 hours for permit applicants + 330 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Administrative Support |
3 |
22.83 |
68.49 |
Engineering Technician |
25 |
39.09 |
977.25 |
Mining Engineer |
10 |
58.60 |
586.00 |
Operations Manager |
2 |
81.63 |
163.26 |
Total |
40 |
|
1,795.00 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.23 is $1,795. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $1,795 x 44 permits = $78,980.
In addition, it takes 7.5 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.23 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 7.5 hours = $248. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $253 x 44 permit applications = $10,912.
Therefore, we estimate that the total wage cost to all respondents is $78,980 for industry + $10,912 for state regulatory authorities = $89,892.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents.
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $100, which translates to a total cost of $4,500 for all applicants (45 applications x $100 per application).
b. Operations, Maintenance, and Services:
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimate of Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of state compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.23 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 60 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to OSMRE for this oversight activity is estimated to be $3,397.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive one application for a new permit for lands and operations for which OSMRE is the regulatory authority, requiring 8 hours to review. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour for 8 hours to review this section of the application, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review this section will be $453 (1 application x $56.61 x 8 hours).
Total Federal Cost
$ 3,397 Oversight
+ $ 453 Federal Programs
$ 3,850 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 1,845 hours approved for this section. Due to an increase in the number of respondents, this request will increase the burden as follows:
1,845 hours currently approved
+ 285 hours due to an adjustment
2,130 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase of $600 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in respondents, for a new total of $4,500.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.24
A. Justification.
1. Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.24, which specify design requirements for roads in permit applications, reflect this requirement. Section 701(28) of SMCRA defines surface coal mining operations as including roads and section 515(b)(18) of SMCRA requires that operators refrain from constructing roads in or near streams.
2. The regulatory authority uses the design requirements for roads in 30 CFR 784.24 to ensure that mining permits adhere to the requirements of the Act with respect to surface coal mining operations in general and road placement in particular.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us), all of which must include the information required by this section. Each applicant requires 20 hours to prepare this information. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 900 hours (45 applications x 20 hours per application).
We estimate that the total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review this portion of the permit application is approximately 198 hours (44 permit applications received by state regulatory authorities x 4.5 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 1,098 hours (900 hours for permit applicants + 198 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Engineering Technician |
10 |
39.09 |
390.9 |
Civil Engineer |
8 |
56.69 |
453.52 |
Operations Manager |
2 |
81.63 |
163.26 |
Total |
20 |
|
1,007.68 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §7840.24 is $1,008. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $1,008 x 45 permits = $45,360.
In addition, it takes 4.5 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.24 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 4.5 hours = $149. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $149 x 44 permit applications = $6,556.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $45,360 for industry + $6,556 for state regulatory authorities = $51,916.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents.
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $50, which translates to a total cost of $2,250 for all applicants (45 applications x $50 per application).
b. Operations, Maintenance, and Services:
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimated Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of state compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.24 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 36 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to the Federal government for this oversight activity is estimated to be $2,038.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive one application for a new permit for lands and operations for which OSMRE is the regulatory authority, requiring 5 hours to review. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour for 5 hours to review this section of the application, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review this section will be $283 (1 application x $56.61 x 5 hours).
Total Federal Cost
$ 2,038 Oversight
+ $ 283 Federal Programs
$ 2,321 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 951 hours approved for this section. Due to an increase in the number of respondents, this request will increase the burden as follows:
951 hours currently approved
+ 147 hours due to adjustments
1,098 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase of $300 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in respondents, for a new total of $2,250.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.25
A. Justification.
1. These regulations, which govern disposal of coal processing waste in abandoned underground mines, have no direct counterpart in SMCRA. However, there is a rational extrapolation of our responsibility to ensure that coal mining operations are conducted in a manner that protects the hydrologic balance, including groundwater systems. Those requirements appear in sections 507(b)(11) and 508(a)(13) and throughout sections 510, 515, and 516 of SMCRA.
2. The regulatory authority uses the information collected under this section to ensure that disposal of coal processing waste in underground mines does not cause material damage to the hydrologic balance or pose a stability problem.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us). Based on discussions with industry representatives, we estimate that 47% (21) of those permit applications include the information required by this section. Each applicant requires 6 hours to prepare this information. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 126 hours (21 applications x 6 hours per application).
The burden for state regulatory authorities to review this portion of the permit application would average 4 hours per application. We estimate that the total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review permit applications for 30 CFR 784.25 will be 80 hours (20 permit applications received by state regulatory authorities x 4 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 206 hours (126 hours for permit applicants + 80 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Mining Engineer |
5 |
58.60 |
293.00 |
Operations Manager |
1 |
81.63 |
81.63 |
Total |
6 |
|
374.63 |
Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.25 is $375. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $375 x 21 permits = $7,875.
In addition, it takes 4 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.25 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 4 hours = $132. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $132 x 20 permit applications = $2,642.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $7,875 for industry + $2,642 for state regulatory authorities = $10,517.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents.
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $100, which translates to a total cost of $2,100 for all applicants (21 applications x $100 per application).
b. Operation, Maintenance, and Services:
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimated Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of state compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.25 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 4 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to the Federal government for this oversight activity is estimated to be $226.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive one application for a new permit for lands and operations for which OSMRE is the regulatory authority, requiring 4 hours to review. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour for 4 hours to review this section of the application, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review this section will be $226 (1 application x $56.61 x 4 hours).
Total Federal Cost
$ 226 Oversight
+ $ 226 Federal Programs
$ 452 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 206 hours approved for this section. We anticipate no changes to this section in hours or non-wage costs.
206 hours currently approved
- 0 hours due to an adjustment
206 hours requested
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement for Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.29
A. Justification.
1. Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.29, which require that the permit application include designs for all stream-channel and other diversions, reflect this requirement. Section 508(a)(5) of SMCRA requires that the application include a plan for the control of surface water drainage. In addition, section 508(a)(13) of SMCRA requires that the application include a detailed description of measures to be taken to ensure the protection of surface water systems.
2. The regulatory authority uses the information provided under this section to ensure that mining operations are designed to protect the hydrologic balance and safely control surface runoff.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us), all of which must include the information required by this section. Each applicant requires 16 hours to prepare this information. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 720 hours (45 applications x 16 hours per application).
The burden for state regulatory authorities to review the information submitted under this section would average 5 hours per application. We estimate that the total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review this portion of the permit application is approximately 220 hours (44 permit applications received by state regulatory authorities x 5 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 940 hours (720 hours for permit applicants + 220 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Administrative Support |
1 |
22.83 |
22.83 |
Mining Engineer |
13 |
58.60 |
761.80 |
Operations Manager |
2 |
81.63 |
163.26 |
Total |
16 |
|
947.89 |
Therefore, the estimated total annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.29 is $948. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $948 x 45 permits = $42,660.
In addition, it takes 5 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.29 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 5 hours = $165. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $165 x 44 permit applications = $7,264.
Therefore, we estimate that the burden to all respondents is $42,660 for industry + $7,264 for state regulatory authorities = $49,924.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents.
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $50, which translates to a total cost of $2,250 for all applicants (45 applications x $50 per application).
b. Operation, Maintenance, and Services:
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimate of Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of state compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.29 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 24 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to the Federal government for this oversight activity is estimated to be $1,359.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive one application for a new permit for lands and operations for which OSMRE is the regulatory authority, requiring 5 hours to review. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review the information will be $283 (1 application x 5 hours per review x $56.61 per hour).
Total Federal Cost
$ 1,359 Oversight
+ $ 283 Federal Programs
$ 1,642 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 814 hours approved for this section. Due to an increase in the number of respondents, this request will increase the burden as follows:
814 hours currently approved
+ 126 hours due to an adjustment
940 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase of $300 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in respondents, for a new total of $2,250.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
Supporting Statement of Reporting Requirements of
Section 784.30
A. Justification.
1. Section 516(d) of SMCRA provides that the permitting requirements of Title V of SMCRA are applicable to surface operations and surface impacts of underground mines, although the Secretary must modify those requirements by rulemaking in recognition of the distinct differences between surface and underground mining. The regulations at 30 CFR 784.30, which require that the permit application include designs for support facilities consistent with the performance standards for those facilities at 30 CFR 817.181, reflect this requirement. The performance standards at 30 CFR 817.181 are derived from the sedimentation control and fish and wildlife protection requirements of sections 516(b)(9) and (11) of SMCRA.
2. The regulatory authority uses the information provided under this section to ensure that support facilities are designed to ensure compliance with performance standards.
3. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
4. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
5. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
6. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
7. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
8. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
9. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
10. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
11. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
12. Reporting and Reviewing Burden
a. Burden Hour Estimates for Respondents
We and the states issued 45 new permits for underground mines during that year (44 by the states and one by us), all of which must include the information required by this section. Each applicant requires 8 hours to prepare this information. Therefore, the annual burden to permit applicants for compliance with this section totals 360 hours (45 applications x 8 hours per application).
The burden for state regulatory authorities to review the information submitted under this section would average 2 hours per application. The total annual burden for state regulatory authorities to review this portion of the permit application is approximately 88 hours (44 permit applications received by state regulatory authorities x 2 hours per application).
Therefore, the total annual burden for all respondents is 448 hours (360 hours for permit applicants + 88 hours for state regulatory authority review).
b. Estimated Annual Wage Cost to Respondents
OSMRE has estimated the wage cost as follows, including benefits as discussed in item 12 in List of Items with Identical Responses:
Industry Wage Cost
Position |
Hour Burden per Response |
Cost Per Hour ($) |
Total Wage Burden ($) |
Engineering Technician |
2 |
39.09 |
78.18 |
Mining Engineer |
5 |
58.60 |
293 |
Operations Manager |
1 |
81.63 |
81.63 |
Total |
8 |
|
452.81 |
Therefore, the estimated total annual wage cost for each industry respondent for §784.30 is $453. The total wage cost to all industry respondents is $453 x 45 permits = $20,385.
In addition, it takes 2 hours for each state regulatory authority to review this section of the permit application.
Using wage costs for state employee engineering technician, we estimate that the wage cost is $33.02 per hour including benefits. Therefore, the estimated annual wage cost for state regulatory authorities to review §784.30 of each permit application is $33.02 per hour x 2 hours = $66. The total wage cost to all state regulatory authorities is $66 x 44 permit applications = $2,904.
Therefore, we estimate that the total wage cost to all respondents is $20,385 for industry + $2,904 for state regulatory authorities = $23,289.
13. Total Annual Non-Wage Cost Burden to Respondents.
a. Capital and Start-Up Costs:
We estimate that non-labor costs for each application average $100, which translates to a total cost of $4,500 for all applicants (45 applications x $100 per application).
b. Operation, Maintenance, and Services:
None other than those associated with customary and usual business practices.
14. Estimated Costs to the Federal Government:
Oversight: In keeping with the current guidance concerning oversight of state program implementation, which de-emphasizes process reviews, OSMRE does not anticipate conducting any significant oversight review of state compliance with the requirements of 30 CFR § 784.30 in the absence of any indication of programmatic problems. If we conduct an oversight review of this topic in one state program per year, that review would require an average of 12 hours at $56.61 per hour (GS-12/5 regulatory program specialist/mining engineer reviewing the application, including 1.5 multiplier for benefits). The annual cost to the Federal government for this oversight activity is estimated to be $679.
Federal Programs: OSMRE estimates that it will annually receive one application for a new permit for lands and operations for which OSMRE is the regulatory authority, requiring 2 hours to review. At an average salary of $56.61 per hour for 2 hours to review this section of the application, the annual wage cost to the Federal government to review this section will be $113 (1 application x $56.61 x 2 hours).
Total Federal Cost
$ 679 Oversight
+ $ 113 Federal Programs
$ 792 Total Federal Cost
15. There are currently 388 hours approved for this section. Due to an increase in the number of respondents, this request will increase the burden as follows:
388 hours currently approved
+ 60 hours due to an adjustment
448 hours requested
This request will also result in a burden increase of $600 for non-wage costs due to the adjustment in respondents, for a new total of $4,500.
16. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
17. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
18. See List of Items with Identical Responses.
| File Type | application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.document |
| Author | Felch, Steve M. |
| File Modified | 0000-00-00 |
| File Created | 2021-01-26 |